Cargo fraud is no longer a fringe issue in the food supply chain industry — it’s a fast-evolving, highly organized threat that’s impacting shippers, brokers, and carriers alike. What was once considered an occasional risk has become a persistent and costly challenge, fueled by digital tools, fragmented systems, and gaps in verification.
As food supply chains grow more complex and time-sensitive, the stakes are even higher. Perishable goods, tight delivery windows, and high shipment volumes make food shippers particularly attractive targets. Understanding how fraud operates, and how to prevent it, has become essential.
At its core, freight fraud exploits fundamental weaknesses in how business is conducted across the supply chain. According to Caney, the conditions are surprisingly simple: “Fraud thrives where there’s anonymity, urgency, and money.”
In today’s supply chain environment, all three are abundant. Digital load boards, email-based communications, and rapidly shifting capacity needs create opportunities for bad actors to impersonate legitimate carriers, intercept loads, or manipulate payment flows.
“If someone can pretend to be someone else, and get paid quickly, you’ve got the perfect conditions for fraud,” Caney explains. The result is a surge in schemes ranging from double brokering to identity spoofing and strategic cargo theft. And as technology lowers the barrier to entry, the problem is accelerating.
“The barriers to entry for fraud have dropped dramatically,” says Caney. “Unfortunately, digital tools have made it easier to scale fraud faster than ever before. Criminals are adapting faster than the industry.”
If there’s a single root cause behind the rise in freight fraud, it’s identity — or the lack of reliable ways to verify it.
“The biggest vulnerability in freight today is identity,” Caney says. “We’ve built an industry on trust, but we haven’t built the infrastructure to verify that trust.”
For decades, relationships and reputation have been the backbone of logistics. But as transactions move online and networks expand, those informal safeguards are no longer enough. “If you don’t know who you’re doing business with, everything else breaks down,” he adds.
This challenge is especially acute for food shippers who rely on a mix of brokers, carriers, and 3PLs. Each handoff introduces another point of risk — particularly when vetting processes are inconsistent or outdated.
Historically, carriers were the primary victims of fraud schemes. Today, that risk has spread. “Fraud used to target carriers. Now brokers and shippers are just as exposed, if not more,” says Caney.
For food shippers, the implications are significant. A single fraudulent load can mean lost product, missed delivery windows, damaged customer relationships, and reputational harm. In an industry where margins are tight and service expectations are high, the impact can be immediate and severe.
Despite the growing threat, many organizations still take a reactive approach, addressing fraud only after it occurs. That mindset is no longer sustainable. “You can’t solve a trust problem without identity,” Caney emphasizes. “Verification has to happen before the load is ever tendered.”
Becoming proactive means investing in stronger carrier vetting processes, leveraging technology for identity verification, and ensuring data accuracy across systems. It also requires internal alignment — making fraud prevention a priority across procurement, logistics, and operations teams. “The industry has to move from reactive to proactive,” he adds.
Ultimately, combating cargo fraud isn’t something any one company can solve alone. The interconnected nature of supply chains means that vulnerabilities in one area can quickly affect others.
“Fraud isn’t a competitive issue, it’s an industry issue,” says Caney. “The more we share information, the harder it becomes for bad actors to operate.” That collaboration can take many forms — from better data sharing between partners to broader adoption of verification standards and technologies. For shippers, it also reinforces the importance of working with trusted, transparent partners who prioritize security.
Now more than ever, professionals consume info on the go. Distributed twice monthly, our "Food For Thought" e-newsletter allows readers to stay informed about timely and relevant industry topics and FSA news whether they're in the office or on the road. Topics range from capacity, rates and supply chain disruption to multimodal transportation strategy, leveraging technology, and talent management and retention. Learn More